Making invisible forces visible · Private review edition
The Hidden Physics of StorytellingTool · Field Theory
Induction
Did a changed condition give someone a reason to act, or a way to act?
Use it when
- Someone has a reason to act and does nothing.
- Someone acts and the draft never shows why or how they could.
- A supporting character’s presence seems to matter and you cannot say how.
Run Removal test first.
Steps
- Name the action and the person who might take it.
- Remove the original prompt. What remains possible or becomes impossible?
- With that prompt still absent, change one surrounding condition.
- Was the action already available? Decide whether the condition supplies a reason, a way, both or neither.
- List every incidental difference before calling the pair controlled.
- State the finding. Mark it undetermined if the scene does not establish it.
Finding line
Whether a changed condition gave someone a reason to act or a way to act.
Example
In Leck’s study (see The Take), the ward sees the parcel go into Ida’s coat. That is a reason to speak. The housekeeper, the adult he could tell, is at market. He has a reason and, for this hour, no way.
First run the Removal test: take the ward out of the study, and nobody in the household can say the parcel moved. Keep him out. Now change one condition: the housekeeper comes back early and is in the scullery when Ida comes down with the sheet.
| Reason to raise the parcel | Way to raise it | |
|---|---|---|
| The ward, as written | Yes: he saw it | Not this hour |
| The housekeeper, in the variant | No: the sheet agrees and nobody has told her | Yes: she is where the sheet is marked |
Finding. The changed condition supplied a way and no reason. In the scene as written the reason and the way sit with different people. Anything that brings the boy’s reason and the housekeeper’s way into one room undoes Ida’s afternoon.
Limit: bringing the housekeeper home changes who Ida meets on the stairs. That is an incidental difference a second draft would have to hold down.
If it misses
If the only useful result is a new way, record that. If neither version establishes why the person acts, the result is undetermined, and the draft may need another beat.
Full treatment: Field Theory chs. 3 and 4.
Keep the result
Fill the comparison card and the decision record on the Desk. Keep the original, the variant, the difference inventory and the reason for your choice.
Open the DeskRead Field Theory