Making invisible forces visible · Private review edition
The Hidden Physics of StorytellingTool · Geography
The refused route
Does the refusal belong to the character or to the rule?
Use it when
- A character avoids an obvious way to their goal and it reads as stubbornness.
- A character turns up wherever the plot needs them.
- You cannot tell whether a choice is personal or forced.
Steps
- Name the goal and the route the character does not take.
- Name one cost or restriction on that route. Does the character know about it?
- In a second version, lower that one cost. Hold the goal and everything else you can.
- Write the choice in both versions. List every incidental difference.
- Say what the comparison suggests and what else could explain it.
- State the finding.
Finding line
Whether the refusal belongs to the character or to the rule.
Example
Ida leaves Leck’s house with the parcel (see The Take). She goes down the kitchen stairs. The front route has a steward’s check on it, so the choice seems to need no tool.
Lower the front route’s one cost. The steward has been called out and his table is empty. Ida knows it, because she passed him in the street.
She stood at the head of the front stairs with her bag. The hall below was empty, the table bare, the street door on the latch. She looked at it for as long as it took to do up her top button. Then she went back along the passage to the kitchen stairs.
She still refuses it. The steward’s check is a real price and would have been enough. It is not the only thing keeping her off those stairs. In eleven years of clearing houses she has come and gone by the yard.
Finding. The refusal has two owners. Part belongs to the rule at the steward’s table and part to Ida. The second part could not be seen until the first was taken away.
If it misses
If every cost has been lowered and the person will not move, stop. The scene is asking a different question. Try Geometry (what they count as winning) or Relativity (what standard they are judging by).
Two draft cards from the same book
Same path, two walkers. Fix one path and one rule at its crossing. Send two people, with one stated difference in what each may show or claim. Write the immediate result for each. Ask whether the result follows from the permission you established or from something you assumed.
Plan view. For action that is hard to follow. Draw the space from above: positions, goal, exits, what lies between. Mark anything invented in a second pen. State each position that matters once, early. In a script, show the layout again after any cut.
Full treatment: Geography chs. 3 to 6.
Keep the result
Fill the comparison card and the decision record on the Desk. Keep the original, the variant, the difference inventory and the reason for your choice.
Open the DeskRead Geography